DS 5 (2011-2018) Review

Written by Andrew Brady
Quick overview
Pros
- It’s different
- Optional ‘watch strap’ leather interior is very cool
- Decent standard kit levels
Cons
- Conventional alternatives are much better
- Suspension is firm to the point of discomfort
- 6EAT automatic transmission is slow and jerky
Overall verdict on the DS 5
"It’s tricky not to see the DS 5 as a significant miss from DS. It’s neither as stylish and sophisticated as the original DS models that it aimed to replicate or as genuinely posh, comfortable and nice to drive as the German saloons it wanted to steal sales from. Perhaps this confused personality is the biggest sign that it was never a bespoke DS model to begin with."

The DS 5 (previously the Citroen DS 5) was Citroen’s push to plush, pitching the large, bold hatchback at big-selling premium saloons like the BMW 3 Series, Audi A4 and Mercedes-Benz C-Class.
The DS badge was meant to evoke memories of the old Citroen DS, a Gallic executive car that created its own unique style when it was launched in the 50s and remains something of a cultish icon to this day. It was a French luxury saloon good enough to take on the best from Germany and, sadly, hasn’t been replicated since.
It's a situation the DS 5 doesn't rectify. Okay, so its ballooned hatchback looks and lashings of chrome gave it its own ‘unique’ appearance, but attractive? Not so much. It's certainly nowhere near as striking as its classic namesake.
While the looks weren’t revolutionary some of the DS 5’s technology was genuinely impressive when it went on sale. Top-of-the-range Hybrid4 versions combined a 2.0-litre diesel engine that turned the front wheels with an electric motor that spun up the rears. That gave you four-wheel drive, but also a short electric-only range that helped the DS 5 return decent fuel economy. The range also included conventional petrol and diesels.
Conventional is a good way to describe how the DS 5 drives. It’s neither as comfortable as a Mercedes nor as fun to drive as a BMW – in fact, it’s some way off matching either. Its ride is firm and flustered over bumps, yet this doesn’t translate into responsive handling and – to cap it all off – the stodgy steering doesn’t inspire much confidence.
At least the interior gets close to matching the premium feel of rivals in period. The vast windscreen is supposed to replicate an aircraft’s cockpit – an analogy that’s reinforced by the roof-mounted controls – and it lets plenty of light wash into the cabin, especially in combination with the optional panoramic glass roof.
Material quality is also reasonable and you get neat touches like the shark tooth buttons on the centre console, leather “watch strap” upholstery and an analogue clock.
Sadly, DS hasn’t managed to combine these quirky details with impressive interior practicality. Tall adults will be fine in the front, but the sweeping roofline does rear-seat headroom no favours even if legroom is fine. Oddoment space is okay but not helped by the tiny glovebox.
You do get a reasonably large boot if you go for one of the conventional models, but that can’t be said of the hybrid car. Packaging problems caused by its electric motor and battery mean its boot is actually significantly smaller than in a Volkswagen Golf – a car that sits a size below the DS – hard to forgive in a car aimed at families.
For this reason and more, it’s tricky not to see the DS 5 as a significant miss from DS. It’s neither as stylish and sophisticated as the original DS models that it aimed to replicate or as genuinely posh, comfortable and nice to drive as the German saloons it wanted to steal sales from. Perhaps this confused personality is the biggest sign that it was never a bespoke DS model to begin with.
Is the DS 5 right for you?
What's the best DS 5 model/engine to choose?
What other cars are similar to the DS 5?
Comfort and design: DS 5 interior
"Design is an area where the DS 5 aimed to be different and that’s apparent the second you climb inside."

It’s boldly styled in the cabin, not to the point of brashness, instead the DS 5’s interior daring to be a little bit different and feeling all the better for it.
There are cool switches around the gear lever, and while roof-mounted controls are not that unusual for things like sunroof blinds, the ability to move the head-up display position with them is DS citing a plane’s cockpit for inspiration.
That aviation effect is heightened by the two glass panels above the driver and passenger’s head, as well as a further one for the rear seating area, adding some light into the interior. The front seats have decent support and adjustment, which is manual on the Elegance model and the driver’s seat getting electric adjustment from Performance Line upwards.
If optioned with the Electric Comfort Pack (£500 at the time), the DS 5 gained seat heating, driver’s electric lumbar adjustment, massage and memory settings and electric adjustment for the passenger. All came with keyless entry and start, dual-zone air conditioning as standard, too.
Quality and finish
Infotainment: touchscreen, USB, nav and stereo in the DS 5
Space and practicality: DS 5 boot space
Handling and ride quality: What is the DS 5 like to drive?
"Given French car firms have long been associated with suspension that focuses on soft, cosseting ride comfort, the DS 5’s appalling ride catches you off balance."

On anything but glass-smooth roads its ride is incredibly busy and, on the worst road surfaces, it’s downright uncomfortable.
Unfortunately, these compromises don’t come with a side order of sporting prowess or engagement, either, so if you’re expecting BMW 3 Series like involvement, forget it.
The suspension’s tuning was revised shortly after the car’s launch to try to improve this, but it wasn’t until the mid-life revisions that DS took the onboard criticism, adding PLV (Pre-loaded Linear Valve, in case you wondered) shock absorbers, increasing the DS 5’s ride height and comfort. It rides best on the 17-inch alloy wheels of the Elegance model, with the comfort diminishing as you climb through Prestige (18-inch wheels) and Performance Line (19-inch) models.
What engines and gearboxes are available in the DS 5?
Refinement and noise levels
Safety equipment: How safe is the DS 5?
Maximum EV range in the DS 5
MPG and fuel costs: What does a DS 5 cost to run?
"Fuel consumption was measured to the old (and famously inaccurate) NEDC standards, so the quoted figures are miles off what you’ll experience in reality."

The diesel line-up is quoted between 62-70mpg, though expect economy of around 40-45mpg in the real world. The petrol will be in the region of 30mpg, despite a quoted near 48mpg.
That Hybrid4 quoted in the 80mpg sphere but, again, expect 45-50mpg in daily driving.
Insurance groups and costs
VED car tax: What is the annual road tax on a DS 5?
How much should you be paying for a used DS 5?
"The older ‘Citroen’ badged models are cheaper, with the highest mileage examples available from around £4000 and topping out at about £12,000."

Trim choices on earlier cars were DStyle, Airdream and DSport, so be sure to check what you’re getting. DS exclusive models went on sale in 2015 and start from about £7000 rising to around £16,000 for a top-of-the-range car sold in 2018.
Trim levels and standard equipment
Ask the heycar experts: common questions
What is the DS 5?
What cars are DS?
What car brands does the PSA Group own?
Is the DS 5 a good car?
Get our latest advice, news and offers
Keep me updated by email with the latest advice, news and offers from heycar.
By submitting you agree to our privacy policy